BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: Sci/Tech
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Friday, 19 October, 2001, 21:20 GMT 22:20 UK
Inquiries launched into BSE blunder
Sheep AP
The flawed research could have led to a massive cull
There has been scathing criticism of UK Government scientists checking for possible BSE in sheep after they admitted they had carried out their tests on cattle brains by mistake.

I was stunned when I heard about it

Sir John Krebs, FSA
The Food Standards Agency said it was stunned by the blunder and called for more research. However, it also insisted that all current evidence suggested British lamb was safe to eat.

Rural Affairs Secretary Margaret Beckett has come under pressure to apologise over the government's handling of the mix-up.

Two top-level inquiries will now try to find out how cow and sheep brain-tissue samples became mixed up at an Institute of Animal Health laboratory in Edinburgh.

Had the mistake not been uncovered, it could have sparked a major food scare and cost the British taxpayer billions of pounds.

Further research

"I was stunned when I heard about it," FSA chairman, Sir John Krebs, told the BBC. "It's a really serious setback for research in this area. Of course, the experiment was aimed at trying to find out if BSE was in sheep in the early 1990s; it's not related to the current situation."

IAH scientists mixed up their samples
Sir John called for more modern techniques to be introduced, which could lead to fast clinical tests for BSE.

Peter Ainsworth, the Conservative opposition spokesman on rural affairs, said: "It beggars belief that it took these scientists four years to work out that the sheep brains they were investigating for BSE were in fact cows' brains.

"This is not only a humiliating blow to the credibility of the Institute, but also a major setback to the vital task of restoring public confidence in our food."

He added: "Margaret Beckett should apologise for the underhand way in which this information was released, explain why it was decided to publish the findings at 1030 at night and sack whoever took this decision."

'Dreadful mistake'

The IAH study, which cost 217,000, looked at infected brain samples gathered in the early 1990s.

What the cross-checking showed was that the samples came from the wrong animal

The concern had been that bovine spongiform encephalopathy - or mad cow disease - might have got into sheep and its symptoms confused with a related disease, scrapie, which has been around for centuries but has never been shown to affect people. And early results from the Edinburgh lab suggested that this might indeed be the case.

But just two days before the final research was due to be presented to the expert committee on BSE - the Spongiform Encephalopathy Advisory Committee (Seac) - it was discovered that tissue samples had been mixed up.

Seac chairman Professor Peter Smith said on Thursday: "It appears to have been a dreadful mistake. I think it's too early yet to conclude that the study was a complete waste of time, but it does look like that might be the case."

The scientists at the IAH were apparently conducting more than one study, and had prepared brain material from both sheep and cattle.

Brain paste

Professor Smith said: "Once it's a paste, a cow brain looks very like a sheep brain. That's no excuse, however - the samples should have been properly labelled - but you can't tell them apart just from their appearance.

Sir John BBC
Sir John: British lamb is safe to eat
"It's hard to come to any other conclusion than that a serious error was made."

The blunder came to light when DNA cross-checking was performed on samples sent to the Laboratory of the Government Chemist.

The FSA continues to advise that British lamb is safe to eat but said tests on current sheep flocks needed to be stepped urgently.

Huge cull

The research error is yet another embarrassing episode in the handling of the BSE crisis in Britain. However, ministers were unbowed by the latest revelations.

Rural affairs minister Elliot Morley said: "If anything, I think consumers should be reassured that the quality control checks showed there were flaws in the tests, and we would have been much more embarrassed as a government if we'd taken some very drastic action, in relation to sheep, on the basis of those flawed tests."

The government said last month that the UK's 20 million sheep and 20 million lambs might have to be destroyed if the initial findings of the IAH research were confirmed.

The precise details of went wrong will now be investigated by both the Institute of Animal Health and the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra).

The BBC's Richard Bilton
"This flawed research means that there is still uncertainty"
FSA chairman Sir John Krebs
"We've always said there is a theoretical risk"
Rural affairs minister Elliot Morley
"There will be an inquiry"





See also:

18 Oct 01 | UK
Sheep BSE research 'flawed'
28 Sep 01 | UK
Q&A: BSE in sheep
09 Feb 01 | UK
UK condemns BSE secrecy
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Sci/Tech stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Sci/Tech stories