Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Wednesday, September 15, 1999 Published at 13:36 GMT 14:36 UK

World: Europe

Analysis: Russia's options on violence

Bomb attacks often force politicians into short-term strategies

By Russian Affairs Analyst Malcolm Haslett

Russian President Boris Yeltsin and Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov have apparently put aside their rivalries - temporarily at least - to face up to the most serious threat yet to post-Soviet Russia's stability.

Terror in Russia
  • Who is to blame?
  • What Russia can do
  • Timeline: The blasts which shook Russia
  • But even if Russia's authorities do unite to combat the threat of more bombings of residential buildings, it is a huge challenge.

    International experience has shown that even when the most stringent measures are applied, the cleverest minds put to work and huge numbers of people put on guard, it is virtually impossible - in the short term - to prevent all acts of political terror.

    Most experts agree that the only final solution to what is widely called 'terrorism' is the long-term political one - in other words to eradicate the grievances which have provoked such horrific acts.

    But since political solutions can take years, indeed decades, governments also have to take short-term preventative measures - and this is what Russia now has to take.


    It is impossible to prevent all acts of terror but it is possible to cut them down to a minimum.

    Security forces in different parts of the world use different approaches. Israel, for example, has resorted to retaliation against Palestinian targets for the attacks on its military and its civilian population - and this retaliation has in some cases involved targets like refugee camps which inevitably caused civilian casualties.

    This is not an approach universally accepted. Its critics argue that it merely prolongs bitterness and conflict - quite apart from the lack of concern with civilian casualties.

    So what is left? The alternative is, even in cases where there is widespread public outrage against the people of violence, to limit the security forces to measures of control and restraint, and to concentrate on detection.

    Rather than target whole groups or a wide range of suspects, this method requires hard work to find hard evidence on the real culprits.

    If whole groups of citizens are victimised, this can worsen the problem rather than cure it.

    The UK learned this lesson early on in Northern Ireland, when wide-ranging arrests of people 'suspected' - sometimes on flimsy evidence - of being Irish Republican activists merely embittered the Catholic population and actually increased the ranks of the activists.

    Long-term approaches

    Sometimes, however, detection can take a lot of time, involving painstaking accumulation of evidence and infiltration of the extremists' ranks.

    While this is taking place the security forces have to mount guard on as many potential targets as is possible.

    It can be a huge and costly operation, and requires lots of stoicism from the public, and responsibility and restraint from politicians and soldiers.

    The Russian public has never lacked stoicism. The big question is, perhaps: Will its politicians desist from their mutual squabbling and unite in showing restraint?

    Advanced options | Search tips

    Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

    Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia

    Relevant Stories

    15 Sep 99 | Europe
    Massive security sweep in Russia

    In this section

    Violence greets Clinton visit

    Russian forces pound Grozny

    EU fraud: a billion dollar bill

    Next steps for peace

    Cardinal may face loan-shark charges

    From Business
    Vodafone takeover battle heats up

    Trans-Turkish pipeline deal signed

    French party seeks new leader

    Jube tube debut

    Athens riots for Clinton visit

    UN envoy discusses Chechnya in Moscow

    Solana new Western European Union chief

    Moldova's PM-designate withdraws

    Chechen government welcomes summit

    In pictures: Clinton's violent welcome

    Georgia protests over Russian 'attack'

    UN chief: No Chechen 'catastrophe'

    New arms control treaty for Europe

    From Business
    Mannesmann fights back

    EU fraud -- a billion-dollar bill

    New moves in Spain's terror scandal

    EU allows labelling of British beef

    UN seeks more security in Chechnya

    Athens riots for Clinton visit

    Russia's media war over Chechnya

    Homeless suffer as quake toll rises

    Analysis: East-West relations must shift